Widening the Frame
A collection of links and resources to help continue the conversation:
Former U.S. President Barack Obama speaks about the urgency of responding to the call to reimagine policing.
History Matters
Here are some general resources on the long history of mistrust between the police and communities of color. As you view and read we encourage you to make connections between the historical past and our contemporary moment. Are there things to learn from this history?
Chief Tony Bouza speaks about the disconnect that can exist between officers and the public. Police Tapes 1977.
Chief Charles Ramsey TedTalk discussing the history of policing and the need for law enforcement needs to shift its perceived mission from one of enforcing the law to one of protecting the rights of all.
You're Nobody 'Till Somebody Kills You: Baltimore, Freddie Gray and the Problem of History
As residents of Maryland and the nation brace for what could potentially be another night of civil unrest in Baltimore, it is important to pause and reflect on what has brought us to the current moment.
editorial by Dr. Yohuru Williams reflecting on what the history of police violence and racial protests can tell us about the present. HuffPost, Jun 29, 2015
Perspectives from Law Enforcement Professionals
Those employed in law enforcement are a wide and diverse group that include police, troopers and sheriffs; investigators, detectives and special agents; and guards, parole officers and civilian operators. They can be found in local, state, county and federal organizations, under independent and sometimes overlapping jurisdictions, with their own training and engagement protocols. There is no singular voice of law enforcement and no one way to characterize how people in those professions think. Here are a few voices that have attempted to help others understand the danger and fear that officers face in the line of duty.
A look at the dangers deputies face. Detroit | Local 4 | WDIV, Apr 6, 2018
TEDx Tryon Talk by law enforcement veteran Dean Crisp, on repairing the often rocky relationship between law enforcement and those they protect and serve. Oct 19, 2016
TEDx Northbrook Library Talk by former officer Shannon Spalding, who, as an undercover narcotics officer with the Chicago Police Department, exposed a ring of corrupt law enforcement agents who terrorized the South Side housing projects of Chicago. July 25, 2018
Conversation with current and former law enforcement officers about "defunding the police," and what reforms they believe are needed to improve relations between them and the communities they serve. PBS NewsHour, April 14, 2021
Legal Considerations
Here are a few resources that document the legal protections extended to police in the United States? As you familiarize yourself with these, here are a few additional things to consider: What are the specific protections extended to police in your community? Is it time to reconsider the legal protections we have extended to police as we seek more equity in the criminal justice system? Are there other means that might balance the socially desirable goal of protecting officers in the performance of their duties with the equally legitimate desire to deter police brutality?
-
David A Graham article reflecting on the legal protections that make it difficult to hold police accountable. The Atlantic, December 29, 2015
-
Article by Amel Ahmed discussing court rulings that provide legal grounds for officers wishing to conduct searches. Al Jazeera America, July 30, 2015
-
Discussion of the high legal threshold for bringing charges against law enforcement, which historically favors the police. Ray Sanchez, CNN, September 26, 2020
-
Judge hands down decision in sentencing hearing of Kim Potter, officer who killed Daunte Wright. ABC News February 18, 2022
Community Resources
Wondering how to respond during an encounter with police? In the aftermath of a troubling incident involving police? So are others! Here are some helpful resources. What might be an effective strategy for your community? What constituents would you need to engage?
-
10 Rules of Survival, created by Mt. Olivet Baptist Church, Columbus, OH.
-
brochure produced by the National Black Police Association
-
David R. Williams, a leading expert on the social influences of health, speaks about the mental and physical toll that police shootings of unarmed Black people have on Black populations in the state where they occur. The Harvard Gazette
-
Reimagining What’s Possible: Next Steps
Here are a few resources on reimaging policing from a number of different perspectives. Which of these seems most promising to you? Which would you adopt and why? What obstacles or challenges do you foresee? How might you address these?
-
ABC News looks at calls to remove police from traffic enforcement in the wake of violent and deadly encounters from routine stops. May 6, 2021
-
Shootings, rescues, near death experiences and constant high-pressure situations all tax our members of law enforcement. What about their mental health? NBC10 Philadelphia, December 22, 2018
-
Chief Danielle Outlaw Tedx Portland Talk on healing historical mistrust by restoring humanity in police authority. July 16, 2018
Suggested Books & Films
Here are a few books and films that explore the issue of race and policing. How might these be used to foster greater understanding and conversation on the issue? What films, documentaries, or books would you add and why?
Fiction
Beacon House Writers, The Day Tajon Got Shot (2017)
Walter Dean Myers, Monster (2001)
Films
Non-Fiction
Paul Butler, Chokehold: Policing Black Men (2018)
Rosa Brooks, Tangled Up in Blue: Policing the American City (2021)
Michael Quinn, Walking with the Devil: The Police Code of Silence (2004)